Spooky Themed Murder Mystery Party Games for Halloween
From eerie woods and haunted cabins to kid-friendly mysteries, here are our top spooky-themed murder mystery games for Halloween.
Halloween is creeping up fast, and there’s no better way to celebrate than by throwing a murder mystery party! Whether you're gathering friends for an in-person party or hosting a virtual game night, murder mystery games create the perfect blend of suspense, strategy, and spooky fun. Plus it’s the perfect way to use those Halloween costumes and give out a few Best Costume awards! We are currently running a 20% off sale on all murder mystery party games.
If you’re looking to add an extra thrill to your Halloween festivities, we’ve got the perfect collection of mystery games to set the scene. From eerie woods and haunted cabins to kid-friendly mysteries, here are our top spooky-themed murder mystery games for Halloween.
The Wych Elm: A True Crime Thriller
Throw the ultimate Halloween party with The Wych Elm! Inspired by a chilling unsolved true crime, this murder mystery game is perfect for spooky nights with friends. Host at home or online for 6–10 players and uncover dark secrets hidden in the woods.
For fans of unsolved mysteries and true crime, The Wych Elm is a chilling, immersive experience based on the real-life mystery of "Bella," whose remains were found inside a tree in 1940s England. Set in the eerie and atmospheric woods, this murder mystery game invites players to explore dark secrets, hidden motives, and the twisted truth behind the victim's identity.
You and your friends will work together (or against each other!) to uncover the truth—who put Bella in the tree, and why? With its eerie ambiance and sinister storylines, The Wych Elm is perfect for true crime aficionados looking for a night of thrills. Designed for 6-10 players, this game can be played in-person or online, making it the ideal choice whether you’re throwing a party or hosting a virtual mystery night with friends.
Host the ultimate Halloween game night with Cabin Number 5! This murder mystery party brings spooky fun, secrets, and shocking reveals to your fall gathering.
Cabin #5: A Creepy Camping Weekend Gone Wrong
Nothing says Halloween like a haunted cabin in the woods, and Cabin #5 delivers all the classic horror vibes. In this game, you and your group are looking forward to a fun weekend away, but things take a dark turn when secrets from the past summers come to life, and it becomes clear that one of you isn’t who they seem.
With its tense atmosphere and edge-of-your-seat twists, Cabin #5 is a surefire way to amp up the fear factor this Halloween. The game is perfect for adding some suspenseful, spine-chilling excitement to your Halloween night.
Host a one-of-a-kind vintage circus murder mystery party with The Curious Carnival! Perfect for 15–24 players, this eerie and whimsical mystery game features fortune tellers, ringmasters, and sinister secrets under the big top. Great for birthdays, Halloween, or themed events.
The Curious Carnival: A Twisted Night at the Big Top
Step right up—if you dare! Nothing says Halloween like a carnival, and The Curious Carnival brings the perfect mix of fun and fright. Join the Petrovic Family Circus, a place full of dazzling tricks and dark secrets. Rumor has it not everyone is happy with the current ringmaster, there are whispers of impossible feats outside the tents, and gossip is flying faster than the trapeze.
With its colorful suspects and shocking twists, The Curious Carnival is a thrilling way to add a little chaos to your Halloween night. It’s perfect for groups who want suspense, laughter, and a touch of magic under the big top.
Wands at the ready! The Spelling Bee is a kid-friendly magical mystery game, perfect for birthdays, classrooms, or family fun nights. Ages 8+.
The Spelling Bee: A Mystery Game for Young Detectives
Looking for a murder mystery game the whole family can enjoy? The Spelling Bee is the perfect introduction to mystery-solving for kids. This fun, interactive game invites young detectives to participate in a magical spelling bee—until one spell goes awry! Instead of dealing with dark themes, this kid-friendly game focuses on solving the mystery of what happened to the Professor.
With an engaging, easy-to-follow storyline, The Spelling Bee is designed to encourage critical thinking, teamwork, and problem-solving while keeping the spooky elements light-hearted. It’s a fantastic way to get children into the Halloween spirit and immerse them in a safe and fun mystery-solving adventure.
Why Choose a Murder Mystery Game for Halloween?
Murder mystery games are a fantastic way to transform any gathering into an interactive, suspense-filled event. They offer a unique blend of immersive role-playing and investigation. that gets everyone involved. Best of all, they bring together all the elements that make Halloween great—spooky settings, eerie backstories, and plenty of surprises! Plus, each game allows your guests to play as characters in the story and dress up, making it an unforgettable experience.
Whether you’re looking to host a classic haunted party with friends or want something more kid-friendly for family night, these spooky-themed games have something for everyone. Each game can be played online or in-person, giving you flexibility depending on how you’re celebrating Halloween this year.
Which Game Will You Play This Halloween?
From the haunted woods of The Wych Elm to the unsettling secrets of Cabin #5 and the fun mystery of The Spelling Bee, we’ve got a game to fit your Halloween vibe. These murder mysteries are sure to keep your guests on the edge of their seats, guessing until the very end. So, what are you waiting for? It’s time to gather your friends, set the scene, and get ready for a night of spooky fun!
Explore all of our Halloween murder mystery games and grab your favorite today.
Make your Halloween unforgettable with spooky murder mystery party themes!
